
Should We Tear Down Monuments?
Chapter 1
The Rise of Monument Removals
G. Warren
Hello, everyone. More things that make you go, Hmm, right? Seems like every time I turn on the TV or scroll through the news, somebody's calling to tear down some statue, or rename a square, or pull up a plaque from a park. And, I mean, look, I'm not talking like little stuff—these are monuments, memorials, things that have stood in public spaces for, well, longer than a lot of us have even been around.
G. Warren
Now, many of these calls lately, they’re focused around statues and memorials tied to racism and slavery here in the United States. Confederate generals, people with pretty troubling records, you know? And you get these stories—Richmond pulling down Jefferson Davis, or Baltimore whisking away monuments in the dead of night. Whole cities just rethinking what they want on display in front of their courthouses and schools. It seems as if now we are so triggered by anything that reminds us of racism or slavery, or any of the problems that we've had in our past, that we must take those things down and remove them from the public square and remove them from public discourse.
G. Warren
I keep thinking back to where I grew up—Roxbury, Massachusetts. back in the 50's and 60's. Inner city life, you know, was quite volatile and sometimes cathotic. Nonetheless, being in Massachusetts did afford me the privilege of grow ingup neck-deep in history. Some of it pretty unsavory, some of it not so good!. But those memorials and plaques all around the city, weren’t just bronze faces or chunks of granite to me as a kid. They were reminders—reminders of what happened, for better or worse. Sometimes I’d walk by monuments I didn’t agree with, or frankly, didn’t even understand back then, but they shaped how I saw the city. They made me curious enough to ask my parents, ask my teachers, “Why’s that statue here? Who was that?” So I wonder, if we just haul them all away, what happens to those conversations? What do we lose? These are the things that make me go Hmmm.
Chapter 2
Confronting History or Erasing It?
G. Warren
What really gets me thinking, are we confronting our history, or are we hiding it? I've heard people say, “If you keep those statues up, you’re honoring the worst parts of our past.” And okay, I get it, I do. You don’t want to glorify the bad guys. But then again, if you remove every trace, don’t you risk erasing the very memory of what happened—a kind of historical amnesia, right? As some wise person once said, "Those who fail to remember history are doomed to repeat it" These are some of the things that make me go Hmmm.
G. Warren
Let's take the Confederate leaders. Their statues! They're painful for a lot of people, especially those whose families suffered under the legacy of slavery and segregation. But isn’t there a way to remember without celebrating? Some cities have moved those statues to museums, or added plaques to explain what really went on. I mean, is there a middle ground where you don’t erase, but you also don’t glorify? I thin k that there is or at least there should be!
G. Warren
And I keep asking myself—does removing a statue actually change or heal people from what they remember? I don't think so. Maybe it shifts what we talk about, but does it actually heal anything? Or are we just kind of sweeping things under the rug because they make us so uncomfortable?
G. Warren
I might be wrong, but, you know, sometimes it feels like we’re just moving pieces on a chessboard instead of dealing with the heart of the problem. It doesn't seem right to me to erase, or hide our past so that we can feel noble and moral about our present.
Chapter 3
Political Parties and the Shadow of the Past
G. Warren
Here’s where I know I get a little controversial—so bear with me. I can’t help but look at all this and wonder, why does the tearing down stop at statues? I mean, if the idea is to get rid of every public reminder of racism and oppression, shouldn’t we be talking about the Democratic Party too? Now, hang on—I know that’s raising some eyebrows, but hear me out.
G. Warren
If there's anything that reminds ME of slavery, racism, oppression, injustice, it is the party who championed all those things for centuries. The Democrat Party was the party of the KKK, the party of segregation, the party of slavery , the party of Jim Crow, the party who actually formed a ENTIRE separate nation so that they would not have to free their slaves. I think it would be therefore appropriate if we're going to do all of this revising of history and removing everything from history that reminds us of all of these horrible things that actually happened in America, then we should also do away with the Democrat Party? I'm waiting to see when The Democrat Party is going to canceled, torn down and removed from the public discourse. Hmmm, I won't hold my breath on that one!
G. Warren
Could it be that tearing down a statue is easier than tearing down the systems that built the statue to begin with. Perhaps the Democrat Party and it's checkered history will be renamed, reimagined, or rebranded! But until that happens, perhaps we should just leave the statues alone?
G. Warren
Anyway, I’m sure this debate isn’t going anywhere soon. I’d love to keep talking about it next time. Thanks for sticking with me today, and, as always, more things to make you go, mm. Until next time, folks, take care.